I had a pair of the Gen 1s and they were awesome. I literally wore them into the ground. Super comfortable right out of the box and I was constantly getting compliments. The maroon lace accent was a really nice touch too. At one point I tried soaking them to clean them (terrible idea) and they basically fell apart — but that’s on me, not the shoe.
The Gen 2 is definitely a bit stiffer at first and didn’t slide on quite as easily. I had to loosen the laces a little, but honestly just wearing them on the drive to the gym broke them in a good amount. They still have that amazing wide toe-box feel, but somehow look more streamlined on foot. My feet actually look smaller in these compared to most shoes — even compared to Gen 1 — which I like because a lot of shoes make me feel like I’m rocking clown feet.
One thing I noticed is the toe box flex isn’t quite as forgiving as Gen 1. Movements like Bulgarian split squats or deep toe-flexion stuff feel a little uncomfortable. But if you’re not doing that kind of training, it probably just means fewer creases and longer-lasting shape.
Also, the packaging is next level. Multiple insole options, extra laces, socks, toe spacers… honestly wild value for $140
Overall, Icarus nailed it. Great shoe. I’m pumped to see more colors. Earth tones, charcoal, khaki… I’d wear these everywhere.
